Care navigation
When and how to get a second opinion
Why second opinions are a normal part of good care, when they are most worthwhile, and how to arrange one with your records in hand.
Key takeaways
- Second opinions are common, respected and often encouraged for major decisions.
- They matter most before major surgery, for serious or rare diagnoses, or when treatment is not working.
- Bring your records, imaging and a clear question you want answered.
A second opinion means asking another qualified clinician to review your diagnosis or treatment plan. It is not a sign of distrust. Most experienced clinicians welcome it, and some insurers require one before certain procedures.
When a second opinion is most worthwhile
- Before major or irreversible surgery
- After a diagnosis of cancer or another serious condition
- For rare or complex conditions
- When different treatment options carry very different risks
- When your symptoms are not improving despite treatment
- When you feel unsure or rushed into a decision
It is usually less useful for straightforward, low-risk problems where guidance is clear.
How to arrange one
- Tell your current clinician. Most are happy to help and can suggest someone. You can also find another specialist yourself.
- Check coverage. Ask your insurer or health system whether second opinions are covered and whether you need a referral.
- Collect your records. Clinic notes, test and pathology results, and imaging (the actual images on disc or a link, not just the reports).
- Write down your question. For example: “Is surgery the best option for me, or could physiotherapy be tried first?”
- Consider a different setting. For complex conditions, a specialist at a larger or academic center may add the most.
Virtual second opinions
Many hospitals offer remote second opinions in which specialists review your records and imaging without an in-person visit. These can be fast and convenient, especially for confirming a pathology diagnosis or a surgical plan.
What if the opinions differ?
Ask each clinician to explain their reasoning and the evidence behind it. Sometimes both options are reasonable and the choice depends on your priorities. A third opinion, or a discussion between the two clinicians, can help. It is your decision — take the time you need unless the situation is urgent.
Need a specialist for a second opinion? Request a free match, and use our visit prep builder to organise your questions.
Free for patients · No obligation
Get matched with the right clinic
Tell us what you need and where. We send up to 3 suitable options, usually within 1–2 business days.
- Independent and free
- Shared only with clinics you approve
- In-person or video visits
Sources and further reading
More in Care navigation
All guidesWhat happens at an annual checkup — and how to get more from it
What a routine adult checkup usually includes, common screening tests by age, vaccines to review, and how to prepare so the visit is worth your time.
Read guide Care navigationHow to choose a clinic: a 12-point checklist
How to check licensing and accreditation, compare costs, read reviews wisely and spot red flags before you book with any clinic.
Read guide Care navigationHow to choose a primary care doctor
What primary care clinicians do, the different types, and a practical checklist for finding one who fits your needs, location and budget.
Read guide